This week I attended my first meeting at the department’s Climate and Diversity Committee. It was the committee’s second meeting as a whole and it seems like we all have our own conceptions about things we would like to see and get done but very little consensus on how to move forward. The discussions were very passionated but mostly very off-topic and distracting. We did manage to go home with a few “homework assignments.” Mine, alongside another committee member, a department staff, is to research mission statements from other departments and help design a mission statement for our department. I did that a little bit but decided to read more about climate and diversity in general, which I will now be calling diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI), although I am not sure if these things also encompass the climate aspect of my committee.
Following the trend on my posts so far, this discussion is something I never formally had while in college and I never formally developed the set of skills required to tackle this topic. My training was very science and biology oriented, learning content and methods and not stopping to think much about the social aspects of what I was doing. I had more exposure to social issues on my teaching classes, student activism groups and by living at a housing cooperative that I am very engaged with. Now, I will attempt to centralize my thoughts and develop a plan of actions to further explore DEI in the academic environment.
A potential starting point for a mission statement, as per homework assigned to me, is: “We strive to have diversity and inclusivity permeate the fabric of our department, aiming to create a welcoming environment in which all students, staff, and faculty are valued.” A mission statement should serve as a guide line and reference for the actions we take as committee and the actions department members take on their daily activities and committees. Based on this mission, we will need to assess our weaknesses as a department and ways to deal with them permanently. Arwa Mahdawi’s TEDx talk suggests that structural changes are required to make hirings (and recruitment) more effective and less biased and that there is no easy way “out” of the DEI issue, solutions must be radical. Most people thinking on the issue make it clear, however, that increasing diversity is not enough and that creating inclusive environments is the key to creating successful welcoming environment to all.
Our committee aims to create surveys to identify DEI issues that we could tackle. I wonder how effective the surveys and our response will be. Dr. Marilyn Sanders Mobley’s TEDx talk makes it clear that acknowledging and addressing biases are at the root of making progress on DEI. She raises self-reflecting questions we could ask ourselves: Who am I? What is my work? How will I contribute? In addition to using these questions for self-reflection, I think we could use them as department-wide self-reflecting tools: Who are we as a department? What is our work as a department? How will we contribute as a department? I definitely have thoughts and ideas about to answer the department questions, but they would be one-sided and would definitely not encompass the thoughts of other students, staff, and faculty. I will try to answer my own self-reflection and also put in words my thoughts about my ideal answers for the department-wide questions.
Who am I? I am a far-from-home Brazilian, black and gay biologist. I am not used to the weather or the culture in Madison, WI. I am not used to the professional interactions I have engaged in and I am not comfortable speaking my mind about science sometimes and even less about non-science issues in the lab context. I talked with my advisor about my time-managing research, how I am attempting to implement it in my working schedule and how I was feeling about the way it was affecting my work. The conversation was awkward and I didn’t have the skills to explain more clearly what I had tried to say, but I forced myself through it. In the end, he asked me to send a short email to the lab with a summary and some links about Kanban. I procrastinated that task but ended up doing it at some point, as short and as detached as I could, but reaching out to the whole lab to talk about non-science issues felt like a transgression, as if I was wasting my time and their time. I guess that is who I am, I have always felt as a out-of-place black, gay, nerd in my social circles, so the only novelty is the increased cultural barrier.
What is my work? As of now, I would say that my only work is to do research and search for academic positions to start applying to during the summer. Gather data. Publish. Work on the skills that will make me more hireable. Learn the specific and broader field better. Gather data. Publish. I still do a bunch of “outreach” – organize the Evolution Seminar Series, attend the ECC meetings, attend the Climate and Diversity meetings, but all those feel like less my work. Maybe my side job. I also have my side side job, then: housing cooperative. In addition to my work at my own house, I am also a part of the personnel committee of my organization at large.
How will I contribute? Honestly, as a student I just want to get done and out of here. The Ph.D. is a very stressful time for me and I wish I could be doing something less stressful. That is barely an answer, though. In my work work, I am contributing by training undergraduate students in scientific tasks and serving as a role model to some extent. I occupy spaces that are not designed for people like me. In my side job, the Climate and Diversity committee is my main space to help, as it is very new and we are all exploring what we can do, I won’t create high hopes, but this post outline my thoughts and some of the ideas I would like to implement and could use this committee for that. In the ESS/ECC, I have intentionally made choices to increase the diversity of speakers at our seminar and will continue to do so. I wonder if we should try another diversity panel soon or maybe just get funding to invite an underrepresented minority (URM) speaker to talk about their work and not about diversity per se. For external speakers, it might be interesting to always try to organize a lunch or breakfast event in which they could talk about their career trajectory and choices. In the housing cooperative, I have asked to join the united people of color caucus (TUPOCC) and will at least pay attention to their actions even if my time and energy won’t allow a further commitment, I will also look into RH traininings and employee training, as an organization we always have DEI in mind during hirings.
For the department, my ideal answers to those questions would go in this direction:
Who are we? A research and teaching department striving to provide the best education and high-quality science. As outlined by Puritty and colleagues (2017), to achieve high-quality science we will need inclusive and diverse environments (Bumpus 2015). DEI is not altruism, it is a necessary step in the road to generate better science and scientists, more minds thinking differently from each other will outperform more homogeneous groups. DEI is necessary to become more attuned with societal challenges, teaching, and problem-solving. That touches question number 2: What is our work? Our work is to produce quality-science and to educate undergraduate and graduate students. This work needs DEI (Woolley et al 2010).
Lastly, how will we contribute? Hiring and recruiting more diverse people is one important step, and to succeed in this goal and retain these people we will need drastic structural changes. It is thought that one of the challenges attracting and retaining URM scientists is that many of us are also passionate about social justice issues and this work is viewed as lesser, not scientific, not validated, a waste of time, by the university. This needs to change. We need to encourage and reward this kind of work. Maybe provide grants, consider it highly during tenure evaluation, create connections with social justice organizations in town or in the state and so serve as link for students, faculty, and staff interested in working with these groups. From everything that I read, this idea of opening space for social engagement for academic positions was the one the hittest closer to home to me. I have thought multiple times about switching to a more socially engaged program, working with education or policy, being more useful to people in need.
When I was working on my IDP part of the questions were related to my personal values and that was used to guide my choices in which career to pursue. After reading about diversity today I am staring at these thoughts again. Are my values are poorly aligned with a faculty position in a research intense institution? I am aware I would like to continue researching and teaching, working with students to solve problems and guiding students in their scientific trajectory. But I also would like to have an impact on the lives of people in the communities I care about. I also would like to have time for myself and my family and friends. There are careers that aligned better with my values but wouldn’t allow me to be in the classroom when students are learning or be in the lab discussing scientific challenges. This might be the conundrum that many URM face during the pipeline to become a scientist. The answer might be that the problem is not that I don’t have the set of values and self-sacrifice to become a scientist, but maybe academia needs a reshape in the values expected of people climbing their ranks. We need people with diverse values and ways to allow them to fulfill these values with intellectual support and in a structured, professional setting – and by that, I mean that we need training on how to act on the things dear to us and not as amateurs. I feel like an amateur right now trying to self teach myself DEI issues, how to engage and how to approach DEI issues, how to find resources, how to think about what I can or cannot do, how to make sure my ideas and projects won’t fall through for being badly designed and low-prioritized in front of my “real work” that needs to get done to get me my degree. We need people with diverse values and also need ways to reward them for the effort and time put into this work. This might be crucial to bringing science outside of the ivory tower. Reshaping the values expected of academics in STEM might work towards bridging scientific knowledge and methods to the general population, tackling anti-science feelings in a genuine way that respects people and invite them into the conversation.
Luckily, I think my attempt to answer these questions from two perspectives touched and summarized a lot of what I read and thought this weekend. Moving forward:
- I will look into what resources are available at my department and campus to get engaged in social issues,
- Think about ways I could use my research, time, and knowledge to collect or analyze data about DEI and how to apply it to the URM communities around me,
- Consider creating spaces to discuss DEI on campus: ESS event? iBio event? Informal conversations?
- Look about possibilities to work with DEI at scientific society level – GSA, Evolution Society,
- Decide whether is too late to start doing it during my Ph.D. or not. Maybe it would be wiser to just focus on working on things that will get me to the finish line and well poised to a postdoc position and then think about DEI at the new institution. I have been here too long, I have done a lot of non-scientific work already.
Last but not list, the Harvard EdCast seems like an amazing resource to think about higher education, the discussions about higher education and how to position myself in that universe. Here is a brief piece about one of their episodes on DEI.